Services

10 min readOrganizational Transformation

How to Tell Your Company's Organizational Structure Is Ineffective

Seven signs that a structure no longer fits the business: headcount grows faster than results, functions overlap, decisions bottleneck at the owner, departments clash.

How to Tell Your Company's Organizational Structure Is Ineffective

A company grows: new positions, departments and managers appear. Payroll goes up, yet running the business somehow doesn't get any easier. There are more and more approvals, decisions are made slowly, and employees complain of overload even though headcount keeps rising.

In situations like this, I would start by analyzing the organizational structure. And I don't mean the neat chart where every position is connected by arrows. I mean how functions, responsibility and authority are actually distributed.

An organizational structure should match the tasks of the business. If the company has changed, grown or launched new lines of business while the structure stayed the same or expanded ad hoc, sooner or later this starts to show in its effectiveness.

The problem is far from always obvious. Sometimes a company pays for duplicated functions, unnecessary approvals and poor allocation of work for years without ever seeing them as a source of financial losses.

Headcount grows faster than results

One of the first indicators I look at is the ratio between headcount, payroll and business results.

Say sales are rising, but personnel costs are growing much faster. Or the company hires new people, yet productivity barely changes.

This doesn't yet mean the company is overstaffed. Perhaps the business is investing in growth, entering new markets or preparing for higher volumes. But the reasons behind this trend need to be understood.

I would look at which functions have appeared recently, what the new employees actually do, how the workload of departments has changed, and what result the company gets from the additional costs.

It helps to analyze more than payroll to revenue: also payroll to gross profit, output per employee, and the ratio of management to production staff. For individual functions, you can calculate the cost of performing operations.

And always look at the indicators over time. A single month, or even a quarter, often doesn't reflect the real picture.

When several departments do the same thing

Duplicated functions often appear unnoticed.

At first a task is assigned to a specific employee. Then the company grows, a new department is created and some functions are handed over to it, but the original person keeps doing them too.

After a while it turns out that several departments prepare similar reports, information is collected from the same sources, and managers spend time reconciling data.

And every employee really is working. Sometimes very hard. The business is simply paying for several versions of the same task.

Of course, duplication shouldn't be confused with necessary control. For example, independent review of financial transactions may be a mandatory part of a risk management system.

But if several departments do the same work for no clear reason, it is worth finding out why the company keeps spending resources on it.

That is why, when analyzing a structure, studying job descriptions is not enough. You need to understand what people actually do.

There are managers, yet the owner still makes the decisions

A fairly common situation. The company has division directors, department heads and deputies, but a large share of decisions still goes through the CEO or the owner.

Expenses, HR matters, interaction between departments, sometimes even routine operational tasks all need sign-off.

As a result, the head of the company is constantly busy with day-to-day issues, and departments get used to waiting for decisions from above.

Here it is important to understand why this happens.

Perhaps the managers lack competencies or experience. Perhaps the owner is not ready to delegate authority. And sometimes duties are formally distributed, but no one has defined the limits of autonomy and responsibility for decisions.

You can't expect a manager to take full responsibility if they can't allocate the necessary resources or make decisions within their own function.

So when I analyze a structure, I always look at responsibility together with authority. One works poorly without the other.

Too many managers, or too much load on one

The number of management positions says nothing about the effectiveness of management in itself.

Sometimes a company adds extra levels of hierarchy trying to solve coordination problems. New deputies, heads of divisions and coordinators appear. Meanwhile the number of approvals grows and the pace of work slows down.

The opposite also happens, when one manager has too many people, departments or completely different functions reporting to them.

They physically can't find time to develop the team, control the quality of work and make the necessary decisions.

Here it is worth analyzing span of control, without trying to bring all departments to the same number of direct reports.

Leading a group of employees who perform standardized operations and managing a team of engineers solving complex technical problems are completely different things.

You need to take into account employee autonomy, the complexity of the work, the level of automation and the volume of management tasks.

Everyone is overloaded, but productivity is low

This is one of the most interesting cases to analyze.

Employees are constantly busy, complain about lack of time and work overtime. Managers ask for more headcount.

But once you look into how functions are distributed, you sometimes find that a significant part of working time goes to repeated operations, manual reporting, approvals and fixing mistakes.

Or a qualified specialist does work that could be handed to an employee with a lower labor cost.

In manufacturing the situation can be even more complicated. One shop lacks staff with the required skills, another has spare working time, but its people aren't trained to perform other operations.

That is why I consider it important to link headcount analysis with an assessment of competencies and actual workload.

Competency matrices, for example, show who can work on specific equipment, which employees are interchangeable, and who can be trained to work in another area.

This helps to plan training and also to make decisions about redeploying staff, temporarily covering for employees and the need for additional headcount.

Before approving a new position, it is useful to find out why the existing resources are not enough.

Departments work, but constantly clash

Sales believes production doesn't meet its commitments. Production complains about procurement. Procurement says the sales team keeps changing plans.

A familiar situation for many companies.

And meetings or calls for better cooperation are far from always helpful here.

Sometimes the problem is that departments work by different rules, have conflicting KPIs and don't understand who is responsible for the overall result.

For example, the sales department wants to increase sales volume. But if new orders are accepted without regard to production capacity, raw material lead times and equipment load, the company may incur extra costs for overtime, urgent logistics and changes to production plans.

Formally, the sales plan is met. But how profitable were those sales?

Situations like this call for an analysis of how departments interact, of end-to-end processes and of how responsibility is distributed.

Sometimes it's enough to change the order approval procedure. Sometimes you have to revise the functions, authority and metrics of several departments at once.

It's unclear who is responsible for the end result

This is another sign I would pay attention to.

Several departments take part in a process, each does its part of the work, but when a problem arises, it is hard to determine who is responsible.

Take an ordinary recruitment and onboarding process.

HR is responsible for finding the candidate, the manager takes part in selection, a mentor trains the new employee. But who is responsible for making sure the person reaches the required skill level and starts performing tasks independently within the set time frame?

If no one holds that responsibility, each participant may consider their work done, even though the business never got the result it expected.

The same happens in sales, procurement, logistics and production.

That is why it is important to define responsibility for individual actions and also for the results of processes that involve several functions.

How organizational structure affects payroll and profit

Optimizing a structure is often seen as cutting headcount. In my view, that approach is too narrow.

Layoffs can quickly reduce payroll, but at the same time create overload, lengthen lead times and lower the quality of work.

It is much more interesting to understand what exactly the company pays its employees for and what result it gets.

For example, if several specialists perform duplicated functions, the distribution of tasks can be revised. If managers spend a large part of their time on approvals, it's worth sorting out authority. If a department is overloaded because of manual operations, it may be better to change the process or automate part of the work.

The outcome is not always a smaller headcount. Sometimes the company gains the ability to handle more work without additional hiring.

In other cases, the freed-up resources can be directed to functions that are truly needed for business growth.

To assess the economic effect, I would look at changes in payroll, productivity, cost of operations, process duration, overtime costs, downtime and administrative expenses.

At the same time, keep in mind that changes in financial indicators are not always due solely to a new organizational structure. They are influenced by production volumes, sales, the cost of resources and many other factors.

Where to start reviewing the organizational structure

I definitely wouldn't start by redrawing the org chart.

First you need to understand what goals the business faces, which processes deliver them and how work is distributed among employees.

Then analyze the actual functions of departments, areas of responsibility, managers' authority, headcount and staff workload.

Competencies deserve special attention. Sometimes the structure looks perfectly logical, but employees and managers lack the skills needed to perform the functions assigned to them.

In that case, changing reporting lines alone won't solve anything.

Conversely, sometimes a company creates additional positions, although the problem could be solved by developing the competencies of current employees or redistributing responsibility.

Only after the analysis does it become clear what exactly needs to change: the structure, processes, headcount, functions or the management model.

And a large-scale reorganization isn't always necessary. Sometimes a few targeted changes produce quite a tangible result.

When to conduct an organizational diagnostic

If a company regularly increases headcount but productivity doesn't grow, managers are overloaded with operational issues, departments are in constant conflict, and personnel costs are rising faster than financial results, I would recommend reviewing the organizational structure.

This is especially relevant when scaling the business, opening new lines of business, changing the production model or moving from management through the owner to management through a team of managers.

An organizational diagnostic should also cover more than HR. It needs to analyze how structure, processes, responsibility, competencies and financial indicators are connected.

Otherwise there is a risk of removing individual symptoms while keeping the causes of ineffectiveness.

In my work, I look at organizational structure first of all in terms of how well it helps the company achieve results and use resources wisely.

If the business keeps growing but managing it becomes more and more difficult and expensive, that is reason enough to look into how its management system is built.

You can read more about how I conduct this kind of diagnostic on the Organizational Transformation page, and a good place to start is an HR audit.

Aleksandra Pismennaya

Author

Aleksandra Pismennaya

16 years in HR. I work at the intersection of organizational design, workforce economics and performance management.

More about me

More articles

All articles