Services

8 min readHR Audit for Businesses

How to calculate the cost of employee turnover and how much money a business loses when employees leave

What makes up the cost of turnover, the formula and a worked example for a 500-person manufacturing company: almost a billion UZS a year, and how to calculate the payback of retention measures.

How to calculate the cost of employee turnover and how much money a business loses when employees leave

Many companies measure employee turnover only as a percentage. HR prepares a monthly report, managers discuss the reasons people leave, and recruiters keep filling vacancies. Yet the company does not always understand how much money it loses because of the constant churn of staff.

For a business, the level of turnover matters, and its financial consequences matter even more. This figure is what lets you judge whether it makes economic sense to revise the pay system, invest in training and onboarding, and develop managers.

What makes up the cost of employee turnover

A company's costs go far beyond the expense of finding a new employee. A resignation sets off a whole chain of processes, and each of them has its own price.

1. Separation costs

  • Time spent by HR specialists, accounting and the line manager.
  • Processing HR paperwork.
  • Handover of work and redistribution of duties.
  • Additional compensation related to termination of employment, where applicable.

2. Losses while the position is vacant

While the position stays vacant, the company either spreads the workload among current employees or loses part of its potential output.

This can show up as overtime payments, equipment downtime, lower production volumes, missed sales targets, delayed deliveries and poorer customer service.

3. Cost of hiring a replacement

The calculation should include:

  • job advertising;
  • recruitment agency fees;
  • the recruiter's working time;
  • the time of managers who take part in interviews;
  • professional testing and candidate assessment;
  • a medical examination, if one is required for employment.

Even if the company uses only free sourcing channels, hiring is never free. The working time of everyone involved in the process has a cost.

4. Onboarding and training costs

A new employee has to learn internal processes, master work standards and acquire the necessary skills.

During this period the company pays for training, a mentor's work, the manager's involvement in onboarding, training materials and additional resources.

For manufacturing companies this may also include safety briefings, qualification tests, extra consumption of raw materials and fixing mistakes.

5. Productivity losses

This is one of the most significant cost items, and companies often leave it out.

A new employee receives a salary but is not always able to deliver results at the level of an experienced specialist right away. Depending on the complexity of the role, reaching the required productivity can take several weeks or months.

These losses are especially noticeable in manufacturing, in sales and in roles that require high technical qualifications.

Formula for calculating the cost of turnover

To calculate the cost of replacing one employee, you can use the following formula:

Cost of replacing an employee = separation costs + losses during the vacancy + hiring costs + onboarding and training costs + productivity losses.

The total cost of turnover for a period is the sum of separation and replacement costs for all employees.

If the roles are similar, for a preliminary estimate it is enough to multiply the number of employees replaced by the average cost of replacing one employee.

For more accurate analytics, however, I recommend calculating separately for each staff category: production workers, engineering and technical specialists, office staff, sales specialists and managers.

The cost of replacing an employee can vary considerably from one category to another.

Example: the cost of turnover at a manufacturing company

Let us take a hypothetical manufacturing company with an average headcount of 500 people.

Over the year, 150 employees left for reasons that count as turnover. All the vacated positions had to be filled.

The turnover rate was:

150 / 500 × 100% = 30%.

Suppose the average salary of a production employee is 5 million UZS, and replacing one employee costs the company the following:

Cost item Cost, UZS
Processing the separation 200,000
Losses while the employee is absent, net of savings on their pay 2,000,000
Hiring a new employee 800,000
Onboarding and training 1,000,000
Productivity losses 2,500,000
Total 6,500,000

So the cost of replacing one employee is 6.5 million UZS.

With 150 resignations followed by replacement, the company's annual costs will be:

150 × 6,500,000 = 975,000,000 UZS.

Almost a billion UZS a year is spent or lost by the company because of employee turnover.

All figures in the example are hypothetical. A real calculation needs the financial and operational data of the specific company.

How to calculate a new employee's productivity losses

For a preliminary estimate, you can use the cost of the working time during which the employee does not yet deliver the required productivity.

Suppose a new employee earns 5 million UZS a month and needs three months to reach target productivity.

Period Productivity Estimated loss, UZS
First month 50% 2,500,000
Second month 75% 1,250,000
Third month 90% 500,000
Total 4,250,000

In this case, 4.25 million UZS is the estimated cost of lost productivity relative to payroll costs.

This is a simplified model that does not directly reflect lost profit. For a more accurate calculation you can use output, contribution margin, sales volume or value added per employee.

It is important to avoid counting the same losses twice under different cost items.

How turnover affects the economics of a business

High turnover can lead to a paradoxical situation: the company increases the HR budget, expands the recruitment team and regularly raises salaries, yet gets no matching growth in productivity.

The reason is that a large share of resources goes into restoring existing workforce capacity instead of developing the business.

The company keeps paying for hiring, training and onboarding instead of investing in upskilling the current team, improving processes and increasing production volumes.

Turnover also puts extra pressure on managers. Instead of working on developing their units, they have to conduct interviews, train newcomers and oversee the correction of mistakes.

How to assess whether retention measures pay off

Let us go back to the example of the manufacturing company with 500 employees.

Suppose the company managed to reduce annual turnover from 30% to 20%.

Indicator Before After
Turnover 30% 20%
Number of resignations 150 100
Average cost of replacing an employee 6.5 million UZS 6.5 million UZS
Annual cost of turnover 975 million UZS 650 million UZS

The potential economic effect is 325 million UZS a year.

If the company invests 100 million UZS in improving onboarding, developing managers and eliminating the causes of resignations, the potential net economic effect will be 225 million UZS.

ROI of retention measures = (economic effect − cost of measures) / cost of measures × 100%.

In our example the ROI is 225%.

This approach allows an HR director to make the case for investing in people in the language of financial indicators. To assess the actual ROI, though, you need to confirm the link between the measures taken and the reduction in turnover.

Which turnover needs to be reduced

Not every resignation harms the business. The departure of a low-performing employee or one whose competencies do not match the role can make economic sense.

That is why the analysis should single out:

  • turnover in the first 30, 60 and 90 days of work;
  • resignations of high-performing employees;
  • turnover in critical positions;
  • turnover by department and by manager;
  • resignations for reasons the company can influence;
  • differences in replacement cost across staff categories.

Sometimes a department with 10% turnover causes the business greater financial losses than a department with 30% turnover. It all depends on employees' qualifications, how hard they are to replace and their impact on operating results.

What data HR needs to collect

To assess the cost of turnover regularly, you need to combine data from HR, finance and operations.

Besides the standard headcount and resignation figures, you should track time to fill vacancies, cost of hiring, retention after the probation period, length of training, time to reach target productivity, overtime costs and losses caused by understaffing.

This kind of analytics helps identify the most problematic departments and also set priorities for investment in people management.

Employee turnover should be seen as one of the factors that affect the cost of production, productivity and profitability of a business.

The HR director's job is to ensure an economically justified level of turnover, at which the company keeps the competencies it needs, controls costs and can deliver on its business goals. Chasing the lowest possible resignation rate is not the goal.

If your company's hiring costs keep growing, departments remain understaffed, or increases in the payroll are not followed by higher productivity, it may be worth starting with a comprehensive diagnostic.

As part of an HR audit, I analyse the causes of turnover, workforce economics, organisational structure and the effectiveness of the current management system to identify where the company is losing resources and which changes can deliver a measurable economic result.

Aleksandra Pismennaya

Author

Aleksandra Pismennaya

16 years in HR. I work at the intersection of organizational design, workforce economics and performance management.

More about me

More articles

All articles